PublicPayData

MTA and City of Buffalo, NY · 2026 pay · 27 people

How much does a police captain make in MTA and City of Buffalo, NY?

$195,506typical pay for full-year police captains in 2026

$155,747 – $223,475what most people earned

Counting everyone paid during 2026, including part-year workers, typical pay was $192,298. Each employer counts with its latest published year (2025 or 2026). Typical pay rose 18.0% from the same employers' year before.

✓ Official data from Open Data Buffalo · Matches the agency's latest release · buffalony.gov ↗✓ Official data from MTA · Matches the agency's latest release · mta.info ↗

Where police captains work

Typical pay at each employer, 2026 (everyone paid).

Highest-paid police captains, 2026

  1. 1Jason WhitenightPolice Captain · Buffalo$279,647
  2. 2Jeremy ConnollyPolice Captain · Buffalo$254,342
  3. 3Shawn SteigerPolice Captain · MTA Headquarters$245,538
  4. 4Joseph A GrecoPolice Captain · MTA Headquarters$242,006
  5. 5Donald MyersPolice Captain · Buffalo$232,390

Common questions

How much does a police captain make in MTA and City of Buffalo, NY?

Full-year police captains were typically paid $195,506 in 2026; most earned between $155,747 and $223,475. Counting all 27 people paid, typical pay was $192,298.

How much of the pay is overtime?

Overtime made up 20.3% of all pay for police captains in 2026.

Which job titles are included?

Everyone whose payroll title is Police Captain, at any level (for example "Police Captain"). Part-time-schedule titles (such as "20 hours") are left out. Senior, supervising and trainee titles have their own pages.

Job titles are written out in full from the payroll's abbreviations (for example "SR CRRECTNL POLC OFCR" → "Senior Correctional Police Officer"). "Typical pay" is the median; "most earned" is the middle half. How we calculate this