New York City · 2026 pay · 23 people
How much does a fitness instructor make in New York City?
$73,844typical pay for full-year fitness instructors in 2026
$65,360 – $78,770what most people earned
Counting everyone paid during 2026, including part-year workers, typical pay was $67,927. Typical pay rose 10.1% from 2025.
✓ Official data from NYC Office of Payroll Administration · Matches the agency's latest release · nyc.gov ↗
Where fitness instructors work
Typical pay at each employer, 2026 (everyone paid).
Highest-paid fitness instructors, 2026
- 1Lane N HershbergerFitness Instructor · Police Department$89,395
- 2Elicia M BreenFitness Instructor · Police Department$88,854
- 3Michael S DeninoFitness Instructor · Police Department$84,175
- 4Raymond M NagleFitness Instructor · Police Department$78,922
- 5Megan L McphilliamyFitness Instructor · Police Department$78,770
Common questions
How much does a fitness instructor make in New York City?
Full-year fitness instructors were typically paid $73,844 in 2026; most earned between $65,360 and $78,770. Counting all 23 people paid, typical pay was $67,927.
How much of the pay is overtime?
Overtime made up 3.5% of all pay for fitness instructors in 2026.
Which job titles are included?
Everyone whose payroll title is Fitness Instructor, at any level (for example "Fitness Instructor"). Part-time-schedule titles (such as "20 hours") are left out. Senior, supervising and trainee titles have their own pages.
Job titles are written out in full from the payroll's abbreviations (for example "SR CRRECTNL POLC OFCR" → "Senior Correctional Police Officer"). "Typical pay" is the median; "most earned" is the middle half. How we calculate this